My cats LOVE these! They play with them, attack them, lick them, and generally have a ball! However, I strongly advise you to cut off the balls on the ends before giving them to your cats. One of mine bit his off and choked on it. Thankfully, he is ok, but I cut all of the balls and the bell off and threw them away immediately.My two furrbabies go nuts for these! They gave opposite personalities yet both benefit from these awesome "toys". I was originally looking for something my 'pica' cat (eats freaking everything non-edible ><) could actually safely play with and chew on. It turned out even better, it helped him throw up tons of bikini strings he had eaten with us unaware that he had been trying to throw up for days (unsuccessfully until we gave him this toy) and a day later finally a whole handful of inedible strings and other crap got thrown up instead of just food or bile. Thank God. Lifesaver ingredients. And his stomach seems to finally be settling and his appetite remains good. The mint does as its supposed to as well, they are drinking more water. Yesss, one less thing to worry about. And! Even my older lazy 12 year old goes completely insane with this toy/treat, I mean I freaked out at first she started running her face everywhere, then I looked it up, the silvervine is a strong euphoric compound that just makes her super almost 'high', happy and more active. She loves it too. I'm truly impressed. She is not a toy playing kind of cat but my gosh she's already chewed more through it than her active little brother. Amazing. Also! My little pica kitten has seemed to normalize and hasn't been super ridiculously eating everything he isn't supposed to (cardboard, foam, strings etc) nearly as much as before. I have no clue how much is to be claimed by this awesome toy/treat but it seems like the reason and I'll definantly be buying more. Really cool product! And researched on my own to be sure all the ingredients are completely safe. Good job guys!The cats love these! We have a lot of cats and only had two of these since they come two in a pack. That didn’t work out so well! We had to instantly buy another pack and hide the two we first received to stop the fighting.These are really interesting toys. They have so many different components to them. They have chew sticks that are catnip. On those, there are catnip balls that the cats like to lick (or rub on if your cats are weird like one or two of ours). There are also some feathers and bells, some Lafite grass and sisal rope.The different things on these toys really seemed to excite the cats and kept them occupied for a lot longer than most toys do. As cats generally are, they are incredibly finicky and that extends to their toys. This one fit into their picky little lives perfectly.I have a prima dona, finicky and lazy cat that doesn't like hardly anything. This product has peaked her interest and use for a few months. I gave one to a friend's cat, who loves it and plays with it constantly. It will eventually wear out after the claws and teeth, but, for these two cats - is seems worth the try.Cats like them, but feathers fall off quickly.Buyer beware: When I read this, and read it several times, I was under the understanding that I would receive "3" of these cat toys. I just now read it again and saw the three cat chew toys. You need to either reword your heading of this item or split them up into several different listings. My cat liked playing with the cat toy once I put it on the end of a stick. The catnip smell did not come through the head very well I had to add more catnip on to the toy. Would not buy again.I don't know whatever made me purchase a stick wrapped in string, but my cat is very glad that I did. It is one of her favorite toys and has not lost its appeal after five months. Five paws up!My one and only complaint is there needs to be a warning that one may get mauled while opening the package. Lol my cats went absolutely crazy. I have 3 cats and immediately ran back here and bought more because I'm a good servant and I knew I may not see another day if they each didn't have their own. (2pack) these are strong and durable. They also have them in other varieties with feathers which is always a fan favorite in my house. I will absolutely buy again.