The Kicker toy was durable and cute but lacked any catnip scent. I have 3 cats and none of them gave the toys interest. There was no catnip smell or scent to the toys. My cats love catnip so if there was any inside they would have gone crazy. Maybe it was possible that the catnip wasn't added before sewing shut. Also it would be great if the kicker had a velcro or zip opening to be able to replace or add new catnip.very durable and solid but they do not smell at all like cat nip and my cats agree.My cat isn’t really aggressive so he doesn’t grab onto these kick sticks. He prefers things he can chase. So they just sit on the floor with a bunch of other kitty toys.My cats liked these fairly well. They weren’t the huge hit I hoped for, but they are somewhat picky about their toys!Seems like there's no catnip on them. My cars never play with them!I took a chance on this good priced three-pack of kick sticks for our trifecta feline brood. Unfortunately they had no catnip smell. I usually go with a higher priced two-pack and have to buy two sets since we're up to three cats now, so I guess you get what you pay for with this bargain set. The kick sticks themselves were colorful, decent sized (smaller than my usuals, but not tiny), and seem to be well made and durable. But the lack of nip aroma to get the cats interested in the first place has left these mostly unplayed with. Won't order again, bummer.My cats weren't really interested in these. Evidently they don't have much of a catnip smell.Great size and cute print. Reasonable price for the three pack. The only downside is that the fabric covering has a slick water repellent like feel to it. The good news is my cats definitely won't be tearing these apart. The bad news is they aren't that interested because they cannot sink their claws or teeth into them.My cat instantly took to these kicker toys! She is very picky with just about everything, and she loves these. Trying to get a picture of her with it was impossible though!Ordered these for my cat, on arrival I couldn't really smell the catnip, very faint smell, would rate higher if there was more than a small ball of catnip in the center of the pillow